Theft Under $5000 Lawyer in Toronto - Defending Your Future Against Minor Theft Charges


Charged with theft under $5000? Sadro Law offers strategic legal defence, immediate support, and a commitment to protecting your reputation.


Call Now for a Free Consultation | Available 24/7 to Discuss Your Case

Understanding the Charge: Theft Under $5000 in Ontario

In Ontario, being charged with theft under $5000 might sound like a “minor” legal issue, but it’s anything but trivial. This charge falls under section 334(b) of the Criminal Code of Canada, and while the name suggests a smaller-scale offence, the consequences can be lasting and serious. Contrary to what the name might imply, this charge can carry consequences that follow you for years—from limiting job opportunities to hindering travel plans and impacting other areas of your future.


Theft under $5000 occurs when someone is accused of taking property or goods without permission, with the intent to permanently deprive the rightful owner. The key factor here is that the value of the stolen items is less than or equal to $5000. Whether it’s a few items from a retail store, a phone, or even merchandise at work, the decisive factor is the intent to steal—not the value of the items.


Many people are surprised to learn that they can face a criminal charge over items that might only be worth a few dollars. The law doesn’t require the theft to be large or elaborate—the combination of intent and the act of taking property without consent is what matters most. Consequently, even first-time offenders, especially those who have never before encountered legal issues, may find themselves daunted by the process.


Here’s the truth: even if the dollar amount is relatively small, theft under $5000 is still a criminal offence under the Criminal Code of Canada. A conviction can result in a permanent criminal record—one that may impact your ability to work, study, travel, or maintain immigration status. And once you’re in the system, a criminal record does not simply disappear.


That’s why at Sadro Law, we treat every theft under $5000 case with the seriousness it deserves. We acknowledge how stressful it can be, particularly for first-time offenders. Our team is dedicated to providing focused, respectful, and strategic representation. We take the time to understand your unique situation and construct a defence strategy aimed at safeguarding your rights, reputation, and future.


By knowing your rights and seeking capable legal support, you can better navigate the complexities of a theft under $5000 charge, ensuring that your story is heard and justice is pursued.

Learn What a Theft Charge Means for You

Types of Theft Charges We Defend

Not all theft charges look the same—and the way they’re treated in court can vary depending on the context, even if the dollar value is under $5,000. In Toronto, most of these offences fall under theft under $5000, but that category includes a range of allegations that come with different legal, personal, and professional consequences.

At Sadro Law, we recognize that the theft under $5000 category encompasses a diverse range of situations, each with distinct legal, personal, and professional repercussions. Our approach focuses on truly understanding your individual situation and carefully handling every case with the attention it requires. Here’s how we approach some of the most common theft-related charges:

1. Shoplifting

Shoplifting often arises in retail environments, where individuals are accused of taking items without payment. Whether it involves a single item or multiple, the Crown treats it seriously—but we acknowledge the reality that mistakes happen—sometimes due to a momentary lapse in judgment or a misunderstanding.



We often push for pre-trial diversion or alternative resolutions, especially for first-time offenders. Our goal is to keep a criminal record off the table and resolve the matter in a way that protects your future.

2. Employee Theft

Unlike shoplifting, this type of theft is seen as a breach of trust, which can result in more aggressive prosecution. This could involve taking money from a till or items from a stockroom, and the employee-employer relationship heightens the allegations.



We look at the full context: Was there undue financial pressure? Were you wrongfully accused? Were protocols followed correctly? Our expertise lies in negotiating resolutions that minimize damage—especially when employment and reputation are on the line.

3. Petty Fraud

Petty fraud involves some element of deception, such as altering barcodes, switching price tags, or misrepresenting an item's cost. While minor in scale, it qualifies as fraud under $5,000 and can raise questions about a person’s integrity.



Our approach considers the human element—was it a one-time incident, and what are the implications of a potential criminal record? Many cases qualify for diversion, and we advocate vigorously for outcomes that do not result in a criminal conviction.

4. Possession of Stolen Property

You don’t have to be the one who committed the theft to be charged—being found with stolen property can lead to criminal charges if the Crown believes you knew, or should have known, that the items were stolen.



This is where careful legal work matters. We explore whether the Crown can actually prove knowledge or intent, and whether there’s a reasonable explanation for your possession of the item. At Sadro Law, we aim to challenge assumptions, raise reasonable doubt, and uphold your right to a fair trial.

5. Using or Attempting to Use Stolen Credit Cards

A charge can arise from using or attempting to use a stolen or unauthorized credit card, even if it involves a single transaction. Sometimes, individuals are unwittingly caught in such situations or are unaware that the card was stolen.


These cases are detailed, relying on surveillance footage, digital records, and witness accounts. We dig into every angle and build a defence based on your version of events—not just the Crown’s. And when appropriate, we work to resolve the case in a way that avoids a criminal conviction.


Although all these offences fall under theft under $5000, our legal strategies are uniquely tailored to each situation. At Sadro Law, we emphasize customised defence, transparent communication, and safeguarding your future—whether by contesting the charge, negotiating an agreeable outcome, or seeking diversion.



Facing legal issues can be intimidating, but you don’t have to go through it alone. Let's discuss your options and chart the path forward together.


What Happens After You’re Charged with Theft Under $5000 in Toronto


So, you’ve found yourself in a bit of a predicament—you’ve been charged with theft under $5000 in Toronto. It’s a tough situation to be in, and you’re likely wondering what’s next. Let’s walk through the process together in a way that’s clear and manageable. We’ll break down what typically happens after a charge is laid and outline a few different scenarios you might face.


Understanding the steps ahead can help ease some of the stress and uncertainty:

  • The Initial Charge and Release

    First things first—what actually happens after you're charged? Typically, if you're accused of theft under $5000, this falls under the category of a “summary conviction offence,” which is considered less severe than an indictable offence.


    In most cases, after you're charged, the police may decide to release you, provided you promise to appear in court on a specified date. You might be released with conditions, such as not contacting certain individuals or attending specific places. This is generally known as being released on an “undertaking.”


    However, if the circumstances are more serious—for example, if you have a prior criminal record or the alleged theft involved breach of trust—the police might keep you in custody until a bail hearing. In such cases, you'll want to prepare for a bail hearing where a judge will decide if you can be released and under what conditions.

  • The First Court Appearance

    Moving onward, your first court appearance is usually a relatively straightforward affair. It's often called a “set date,” and it primarily serves to let the court know how you plan to proceed with your charge. It won't be a trial or where you submit evidence, but rather a way for the legal process to keep moving.


    At this point, having a lawyer, or at least getting some legal advice, is advisable. A legal professional can guide you on whether you should plead guilty or not guilty or if there's a chance the charges might be withdrawn or resolved alternatively.

  • What If You Plead Not Guilty?

    Choosing to plead not guilty means your case will advance to trial. This means the Crown (the prosecutor) must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you committed the offence.


    Before the trial, there are a few key steps, including:

    • Disclosure: where the Crown provides the evidence they have against you
    • Pre-trial meetings: where your lawyer and the Crown may discuss the case to see if there’s room for resolution or if trial dates should be set

    This stage is often where strong legal advocacy can lead to charges being reduced or withdrawn.


  • The Trial Process

    If your matter does go to trial, the process involves both sides presenting their cases. Witnesses may be called, evidence reviewed, and a judge (occasionally a jury, but rarely in theft under $5000 cases) will render a verdict.


    Trials can be time-consuming, legally complex, and emotionally draining. Having an experienced criminal defence lawyer is essential to guide you through this stage and effectively challenge the Crown’s case.

  • What if You Plead Guilty?

    On the flip side, if the evidence against you is strong and you choose to plead guilty, the process shifts toward sentencing. A guilty plea can sometimes result in more lenient sentencing because it shows the court you're taking responsibility for your actions.


    Sentences for theft under $5000 can vary greatly and may include:

    • Fines
    • Probation
    • Community service
    • A conditional or absolute discharge (meaning no conviction is registered, under certain conditions)

  • Diversion Programs

    But wait—there’s another option that many people don’t know about: diversion programs. These are often available to first-time offenders and can allow you to avoid the traditional court process altogether.


    Diversion might include things like:

    • Attending theft awareness or counselling programs
    • Performing community service
    • Writing a letter of apology or participating in restorative justice

    If you successfully complete a diversion program, the charge can be withdrawn—meaning no conviction and no criminal record.


    Being charged with theft under $5000 is a journey with many potential paths, and navigating it can certainly feel daunting. Remember, no two cases are identical, so the choices you make should be well-informed and considerate of your unique situation.

Get Step-by-Step Legal Guidance

Why You Need a Criminal Defence Lawyer for Theft Under $5000—and Why Sadro Law Is the Right Fit

A charge of theft under $5000 might appear to be an uncomplicated matter at first, but the reality is that even seemingly “low-level” offences can carry lasting consequences. What starts as a single charge can swiftly lead to a permanent criminal record with long-term consequences, affecting a multitude of life facets such as job prospects, international travel, and personal relationships. This is precisely why engaging a dedicated criminal defence lawyer is not merely beneficial—it is essential.


At Sadro Law, we understand what’s at stake. We don’t see your case as just another file—we see it as your future that needs safeguarding.


The Real-World Impact of a Theft Charge

Let’s be clear—a conviction for theft under $5000 is not a minor matter. Such a charge can lead to:

  • A criminal record, which can restrict employment opportunities and impact professional licensing
  • Challenges in travelling, especially to countries like the United States
  • Strained personal relationships, particularly if the incident involved acquaintances or loved ones
  • Potential issues with immigration status, if you’re not a citizen

Thus, you need more than just legal representation; you require a strategic legal plan tailored to your unique situation.


Why Clients Choose Sadro Law

So, why trust us with your defence?


Deep Expertise in Criminal Law

We specialize in criminal defence and we've mastered the intricacies of theft charges in Ontario. Whether it’s a case of shoplifting, a work-related accusation, or alleged possession of stolen property, we bring keen insight and meticulous precision to each defence strategy we develop.


A Tailored, Thoughtful Approach

At Sadro Law, no two clients are treated the same. From day one, we invest time in understanding your background, concerns, and the details that are pivotal to your case. We design a strategy that mirrors you, rather than just addressing the case file.


Proven Negotiation and Advocacy Skills

While we're ready to take cases to trial, we are also aware that many theft charges can be favorably resolved before reaching that point. Whether through diversion programs, charge dismissals, or reduced sentencing, we pursue the most favorable resolution possible.


Clarity and Communication, Every Step of the Way

The legal process can feel overwhelming. That's why we make it a point to keep you informed at every stage—addressing your questions, clearly explaining your options, and ensuring you're never left in the dark about the developments in your case.


A Track Record You Can Rely On

Our history of positive outcomes—ranging from charge dismissals and discharges to acquittals—demonstrates our commitment and expertise. At Sadro Law, we take pride in our work because we understand what a successful defence means for your life beyond the confines of the courtroom.



More Than Legal Representation—We’re On Your Side

Choosing Sadro Law means selecting a team that prioritizes your future just as much as you do. We don't just represent clients—we advocate for people. People who’ve made mistakes, been misunderstood, or simply need someone in their corner to make sure their rights are protected.

When you're facing a theft charge, you shouldn’t have to face it alone. Let us help you move forward with confidence—and with the right defence behind you.

Talk to a Defence Lawyer Today

Fighting Theft Under $5000 Charges—Our Approach

Facing a charge of theft under $5000 can be daunting, leaving you uncertain about the next steps, potential outcomes, and the impact on your future. At Sadro Law, we stand by your side, ready to guide you through each phase—with a clear strategy, practical advice, and a strong commitment to your defence. We don’t just represent you—we fight for your future.

Every legal matter we handle is unique, but our approach is grounded in adaptable core strategies tailored to your specific situation. Here’s our method for defending against theft under $5000 charges:

We begin with a detailed review of your case. This includes examining the evidence, police notes, surveillance footage, and any statements made by witnesses or involved parties. In this initial phase, we look for inconsistencies, procedural mistakes, and any indications of rights violations. This detailed review often uncovers weaknesses in the Crown’s case, which can be advantageous for your defence.

Evidence can make or break a case—but it must be solid, properly collected, and legally admissible. We evaluate the reliability of witness testimony, the precision and importance of any recorded footage, and the adherence to legal procedures. If the evidence does not withstand close examination, we seek to have it excluded or contested in court.

Crafting an effective legal strategy involves pinpointing the most appropriate defences. These vary from case to case, but here are some of the most common and effective defences we may raise, depending on the facts:

  • Lack of Intent: We might demonstrate that there was never an intention to permanently deprive the owner of their property—an element the Crown must establish in any theft case.
  • Mistaken Identity: If there's any doubt about who was actually involved, especially in cases relying on video surveillance or witness descriptions, we challenge the reliability of that identification.
  • Consent: In some cases, we can prove that the property owner granted permission for the item to be taken, nullifying the theft allegation.
  • Mistake of Fact: We could argue that you had a sincere and reasonable belief that you were entitled to the property, such as thinking it was yours or considered abandoned.

These defences aren’t just technicalities—they can be powerful tools in securing a withdrawal, an acquittal, or a significantly reduced outcome.

For numerous first-time offenders, we pursue options like diversion programs that can resolve charges without resulting in a criminal record. This often involves community service, restitution, or educational programs. Diversion is a critical option we consider early, advocating strongly when it aligns with your best interests.

Not all cases go to trial—and many shouldn’t. Our team is experienced in negotiating with the Crown to seek reduced charges, better sentencing positions, or alternative resolutions that serve your best interest. Through pre-trial dialogues or formal negotiations, our focus remains clear: safeguarding your future.

If trial is the best option, we prepare thoroughly and advocate forcefully. This entails crafting compelling arguments, preparing witnesses, and rigorously contesting the prosecution’s narrative. Our goal is clear: to raise doubt, safeguard your rights, and work toward the best possible outcome.


Throughout the entire process, we keep you informed and confident every step of the way. Legal jargon is translated into accessible language, and we remain available to answer your questions. You’ll never feel uninformed—because knowledge is key to being prepared.

Start Building Your Defence Strategy

Sadro Law: Focused on Your Outcome, Committed to Your Future


At Sadro Law, we understand that being charged with theft under $5000 isn’t just a legal matter—it’s a deeply personal and often daunting journey that can leave you feeling uncertain about your future, your reputation, and the potential impacts on your family and career. That’s why our approach extends beyond just legal expertise. We are dedicated to providing calm, experienced guidance that is devoid of judgment and firmly rooted in practical solutions tailored to your situation.


We believe that every client deserves a defence that not only reflects but also addresses the specifics of the case while recognizing the human story behind it. From day one, we prioritize listening to you, understanding your unique concerns, and crafting a strategy that champions your best interests. Be it negotiating an early resolution or meticulously preparing for a trial, your case receives the diligence and respect it warrants, as we are acutely aware of what is at stake for you.


Moving forward after a charge begins with the right legal support. With Sadro Law, you benefit from a team that steadfastly supports you, focusing on achieving the most favourable outcome and safeguarding what matters most: your future.


Reach out today for a free, confidential consultation. We’ll explain your options, answer your questions, and help you take the next step—because your future deserves strong, strategic defence.

Book Your Free, Confidential Consultation

See What Our Clients Have to Say

Frequently Asked Questions

If you've been charged with theft under $5000 in Toronto, it's completely natural to have questions—and probably a lot of them. Below, we’ve answered some of the most common questions so you can feel more informed and less overwhelmed as you navigate what's ahead.

  • Is theft under $5000 considered a criminal offence in Canada?

    Yes, theft under $5000 is a criminal offence under the Criminal Code of Canada. It can lead to serious consequences, including a criminal record, fines, or even jail time.If you’re facing theft under $5000 charges, Sadro Law can provide trusted legal advice and representation to defend your rights and work towards limiting possible consequences.

  • What’s the difference between theft under $5000 and theft over $5000?

    The main difference between theft under $5000 and theft over $5000 is the value of the stolen property. Theft under $5000 is considered a less severe offence compared to theft over $5000, which carries heavier penalties. We can provide expert legal guidance regardless of the value involved, ensuring you understand your charges and options.

  • Can I be charged with theft under $5000 if I didn’t actually leave the store with the item?

    Leaving the store isn’t always necessary for a theft under $5,000 charge to be laid. In some cases, actions like concealing an item or altering price tags can demonstrate intent to steal, which may be enough for the police to proceed with charges. Sadro Law can help you understand your situation and build a strong defence tailored to the facts of your case.

  • Can I fight the charge if it was an honest mistake?

    Yes, you can fight a theft charge if it was an honest mistake. Proving the lack of intent to steal is crucial in such cases. We can help gather evidence, present your side of the story, and negotiate with prosecutors to potentially reduce or dismiss charges.

  • How long will my case take to resolve?

    The time needed to resolve a theft under $5000 case in Toronto can vary based on a number of factors, including the complexity of the case and court availability. Cases can sometimes take several months to reach a resolution. Sadro Law is committed to guiding you through the process efficiently, keeping you informed every step of the way.

  • How quickly should I contact a lawyer after being charged?

    It's important to contact a lawyer as soon as possible after being charged with theft under $5000 to ensure your rights are protected. Early legal guidance is key to avoiding decisions that could negatively affect your case. At Sadro Law, we act quickly to support you, ensuring you understand the process and are prepared to defend yourself effectively.

A Commitment to Excellence Across All Legal Services

At Sadro Law, we recognize that navigating the legal system in Toronto can be one of life's most challenging experiences. That's why we prioritize a personalized approach for each client to ensure your needs are meticulously addressed. Across our diverse range of services, whether you're dealing with criminal charges, navigating the complexities of licence suspensions, or seeking to remove a criminal record, we bring a wealth of experience and tailored strategies to the table. Our team, based in Toronto and proficient in areas such as assault and impaired driving cases, collaborates with you to develop a robust legal strategy aimed at achieving your goals. With Sadro Law, you can expect dedicated attention, expert guidance, and a steadfast commitment to securing a favorable outcome.

Our Practice Areas →

Your Defence Starts Here

Being charged with theft under $5000 can have a lasting impact on your future. At Sadro Law, we move quickly to protect your rights, reputation, and record. Our experienced Toronto theft lawyers provide focused, strategic, and confidential legal support from the moment you’re charged—challenging the evidence, negotiating for the best outcome, and working tirelessly to keep your future on track.


Free Consultation – No Obligation

Tell us about your case. We’ll review your situation and explain your best legal options — confidentially and without pressure.


Why Choose Sadro Law

  • Toronto-based criminal defence firm
  • Proven courtroom results
  • Personal, compassionate guidance
  • Available 24/7 for urgent legal matters

Request a Free Consultation

Criminal Law Form

What Happens After You Contact Us

  1. Request a free, no-obligation consultation by filling out a short form.

2. Our theft under $5000 lawyers will contact you promptly to discuss your situation.

  1. After assessing your case and goals, we’ll create a clear defence strategy and take immediate action on your behalf.

Who We Work With 

We are working with many top associations

toronto lawyers association
Ontario bar association
Criminal Lawyers Association the voice of creminal defense bar
American bar association defending liberty
law society of Ontario